Driver license nightmare (part 3)

Note from Seth: if you haven’t read part 1 and part 2 of my driver license nightmare, you’ll want to start there.

When I saw the outside of the envelope with a PennDOT return address I thought my nightmare was just about over. Finally, I could be cleared to get a driver license. Then I opened the envelope.

Here is a picture of the letter (edited to prevent super-easy identity theft):

So, PennDOT has stated that I’m not MICHAEL SMITH. Perfect.

Back to the phones I go. First, I call up UDOT and have a conversation with a guy named Chuck. Chuck is actually pretty helpful, unlike the previous unnamed lady I had spoken with. I tell Chuck about the letter, and that it says that I’m not Michael Smith. He chuckles and says, “Yeah, that’s not going to work.”

I then tell him about my dealings with Lucille at PennDOT and her troubles looking up the record, and how this has obviously confused her terribly. Then Chuck says something that leaves me speechless:

“Do you want the guy’s driver license number?”

I don’t know whether to laugh or to cry. I don’t know how to respond. I feel like I could strangle the unnamed UDOT lady who told me she couldn’t give out the number and couldn’t make outbound calls. It wouldn’t even register on my conscience.

When I finally compose myself and prepare to write down the driver license number for the Michael Johnson fellow who is in trouble in Pennsylvania I get another shock to the system — the number Chuck gives to me is the same number on the letter.

I’m no Sherlock Holmes, but here is what I think happened: Sometime before lunch, Lucille managed to find correct guy (Michael Johnson of Pennsylvania) in the system. Now confident in her considerable abilities, she wrote down his license number on my letter, and in the space of two paragraphs forgot the name of the person she had been investigating. She finished the letter, mailed it, and then went to lunch. So I got a letter saying I’m not that MICHAEL SMITH instead of that Michael Johnson.

I thank Chuck for being the one semi-helpful state government representative in apparently the entire nation, and then call PennDOT. I don’t ask for Lucille when Katherine answers (I’ll play the odds that I can’t get another less-helpful person than Lucille). I tell her what happened, explain my theory, and give her the driver license number of the Pennsylvania Michael Johnson. She puts me on hold for a few minutes, and when she returns she explains that she’s just going to send me a new letter herself. I thank her and hang up, consigned to wait for another letter, and possibly another mistake.

A week passes. Manina calls me at work and tells me that we received another letter from PennDOT. She tells me, “You’re not going to believe this, but this one says that you’re not MICAH JOHNSON.”

I take the bait for a few seconds, considering if I should just start forging documents or going without a valid license for the rest of my life. Then I can tell she’s joking and that I can finally get my name cleared and get my license renewed.

All I have to do now is go back the DMV driver license division and go through some routine paperwork. What else could possibly go wrong?

Join the Conversation

  1. Unknown's avatar
  2. Unknown's avatar
  3. maninajo's avatar
  4. Unknown's avatar
  5. Unknown's avatar
  6. Unknown's avatar

11 Comments

  1. you’ve been cracking me up with this entire story. thank you so much for documenting it and letting all of us laugh at it along with you. although, you may not have been laughing quite so much…a little yelling has probably been mixed in with your laughter.

    Like

  2. So… now that you are free to be whoever and whatever your “self” wants to be, will your new license show your new identity: Michelle Sabrina Johnston? (I just thought that would go better with your new “biker” look.) 🙂

    Like

  3. I am currently going through the same thing with my licence. Can you help me with any contact information. I have been working on this for 2 months now and have not gotten any where with it.

    Like

  4. I stumbled upon this story because I am literally going through this with PA when trying to change my license from NH to VT due to moving. Where is part 4!? I want to get this fixed ASAP and need to know what to expect and try to be proactive. BTW, this sort of thing happens to me “Michael Smith” regularly =[

    Like

  5. Dealing with these clowns is a big pain in the seat cushions. I’ve waited TWO WEEKS for my letter to renew my CO license; nothing received. I called and they said they can’t find my record in processing. I gave them the tracking number of my over-night package and the name of the person that signed for it. They said they would ‘look into it’ and it would take on full day to process and ten days to receive the letter. I told them I sent the package two weeks ago and heard the same story two weeks ago. How can they “re-process” the request if they don’t know where the package I sent is? The PA NDR is a disaster. I’ll be researching who runs this nut farm and contact him/her directly.

    Like

  6. Same here – happened in 2010, didn’t happen in 2014 when I tried to renew, but was back in 2018 and I have been calling and writing letters for three months and have gotten no where. If anybody has a magic answer tot his I would love to hear it

    Like

  7. Going through this exact situation now too, moved from NY to MN – PA flagged me because I have a similar name and birth date to someone in their state with a suspended driver’s license. Got my letter from PennDOT PDPS Unit confirming I am not the person in PA, but now the Minnesota DMV still won’t give me a license with just this letter because it’s not actually cleared up in the computer – PA is still flagging me in the computer even though they sent this letter. These agencies are a mess. No one actually talks to each other. And they just want to dismiss you and take the next person in line. Agree, it seems the real problem lies with the PA NDR and whatever computer system is flagging all of us just because we have similar names to others.

    Like

Leave a comment

Leave a reply to Rick Cancel reply